On the issue of gravitational instability of the Sun protoplanetary disk

G. V. Dolgoleva ; M. S. Legkostupov ; L. A. Pliner

Matematičeskoe modelirovanie, Tome 30 (2018) no. 2, pp. 130-148.

Résumé

With the purpose of study of physical processes that take place at formation of the planetary systems of the Sun, gravitational instability of a homogeneous isotropic infinite gravitating gaseous medium was investigated. There were considered the analytical and numerical solutions of the motion equations of such medium in two approximations: "cold" gas and gas at the finite temperature. There were obtained real solutions, describing the behavior of homogeneous medium wave disturbances, and single disturbances. Waves of gravitational instability, the amplitude of which is growing exponentially, and the highs and lows of this wave, as well as its nodal points, retain its position in space, follow the basic laws of Jeans model. The authors interpret this wave of instability as an analogue protoplanetary rings that can be formed in protoplanetary disks. According to the results of numerical calculations homogeneous gravitating medium reaction to the initial single perturbation of its density is significantly different from the laws of Jeans model. Instability localized initial perturbations extends to the region $\lambda\lambda_J$, although in this case the growth of density perturbations is considerably less than when $\lambda>\lambda_J$. It was found that the gravitational instability in the region $\lambda>\lambda_J$ suppress sound. It is shown that without taking into account the rotation of the medium of the Sun protoplanetary disk its critical density in the event of a large-scale gravitational instability to four orders of magnitude is less than the critical density, obtained in the framework of the theory of formation of planets by accumulation of solids and particles.

Détail

Keywords: homogeneous isotropic gas medium, gravitational instability, dispersion equation, sound wave, wave of gravitational instability.

Bibliographie

[1] A.V. Zabrodin, M.S. Legkostupov, L.A. Pliner, V.A. Cherkashin, A.V. Severin, Mekhanizm akkumuliatsii planetarnykh tel, Otchet IPM im. M.V. Keldysha RAN (itogovyi) / Programma No 25 fundamentalnykh issledovanii Prezidiuma RAN, inv. No 8-2-04, 2004, 40 pp.

[2] A.V. Zabrodin, M.S. Legkostupov, L.A. Pliner, E.A. Zabrodina, K.V. Manukovskii, Chislennoe modelirovanie evoliutsii protoplanetnogo diska Solntsa na nachalnou ee stadii, Otchet IPM im. M.V. Keldysha RAN (itogovyi) / Programma No 25 fundamentalnykh issledovanii Prezidiuma RAN, inv. No 8-3-06, 2006, 47 pp.

[3] A.V. Zabrodin, E.A. Zabrodina, M.S. Legkostupov, K.V. Manukovskii, L.A. Pliner, “Nekotorye modeli opisaniia protoplanetnogo diska Solntsa na nachalnou stadii ego evoliutsii”, Keldysh Institute preprints, 2006, 070, 44 pp.

[4] A.V. Zabrodin, E.A. Zabrodina, M.S. Legkostupov, K.V. Manukovskii, L.A. Pliner, “Nekotorye modeli opisaniia protoplanetnogo diska Solntsa na nachalnou stadii ego evoliutsii”, Problemy zarozhdeniia i evoliutsii biosfery, ed. E.M. Galimov, Librokov, M., 2008, 297–316

[5] K.V. Brushlinskii, L.A. Pliner, E.A. Zabrodina, I.S. Menshov, V.T. Zhukov, G.V. Dolgoleva, M.S. Legkostupov, “Gravitational instability in the proto-planet disk”, III International conference BioSphere Origin and Evolution, Abstracts (Rithymno, Crete, Greece, october 16–20, 2011), 31–33

[6] K.V. Brushlinskii, G.V. Dolgoleva, V.T. Zhukov, E.A. Zabrodina, M.S. Legkostupov, I.S. Menshov, L.A. Pliner, “K voprosu ob evoliutsii protoplanetnogo diska Solntsa”, Problemy zarozhdeniia i evoliutsii biosfery, ed. E.M. Galimov, Krasand, M., 2013, 33–46

[7] M.S. Legkostupov, “K voprosu o gravitatsiinnoi neustoichivosti protoplanetnogo diska Solntsa. Ch. I. Postanovka zadachi”, Keldysh Institute preprints, 2014, 034, 19 pp.

[8] M.S. Legkostupov, “K voprosu o gravitatsiinnoi neustoichivosti protoplanetnogo diska Solntsa. Ch. II. Dispersionnye uravneniia”, Keldysh Institute preprints, 2014, 035, 33 pp.

[9] M.S. Legkostupov, “K voprosu o gravitatsiinnoi neustoichivosti protoplanetnogo diska Solntsa. Ch. III. K razvitiiu i obosnovaniiu modeli”, Keldysh Institute preprints, 2014, 036, 24 pp.

[10] V.S. Safronov, Evoliutsiia doplanetnogo oblaka i obrazovanie Zemli i planet, Nauka, M., 1969, 244 pp.

[11] A.V. Vitiazev, G.V. Pechernikova, V.S. Safronov, Planety zemnoi gruppy: Proiskhozhdenie i ranniaia evoliutsiia, Nauka, M., 1990, 296 pp.

[12] T. Gold, “Problems requiring solution”, Origin of solar system, eds. R. Jastrow, A. Cameron, Acad. Press, N.Y.–London, 1963, 171 | DOI

[13] T.M. Eneev, N.N. Kozlov, “Model akkumuliatsionnogo protsessa formirovaniia planetnykh sistem”, Astr. vest., XV:2 (1981), 80–94

[14] V.N. Larin, Gipoteza iznachalno gidridnoi Zemli, Nedra, M., 1980, 216 pp.

[15] O.L. Kuskov, V.A. Dorofeeva, V.A. Kronrod, A.B. Makalkin, Sistemy Iupitera i Saturna: Formirovanie, sostav i vnutrennee stroenie krupnykh sputnikov, LKI, M., 2009, 576 pp.

[16] M. Sekiya, H. Takeda, Were planetesimals formed by dust accretion in the solar nebula?, Earth Planets Space, 55 (2003), 263–269 | DOI | MR

[17] E.I. Chiang, “Dust in Protoplanetary Disks”, Astrophysics of Dust, Proceed. Conf. (26–30 May 2004), ASP Conference Series, 309

[18] V.L. Poliachenko, A.M. Fridman, “O zakone planetnykh rasstoianii”, Astr. zh., 49:1 (1972), 157–164

[19] V.L. Poliachenko, A.M. Fridman, Ravnovesie i ustoichivost gravitiruiushchikh sistem, Nauka, M., 1976, 447 pp.

[20] N.N. Kozlov, T.M. Eneev, “Chislennoe modelirovanie prochessa obrazovaniia planet iz protoplanetnogo diska”, Keldysh Institute preprints, 1977, 134

[21] T.M. Eneev, N.N. Kozlov, “Model akkumuliatsionnogo protsessa formirovaniia planetnykh sistem”, Astr. vest., XV:3 (1981), 131–140

[22] T.M. Eneev, “Koltsevoe szhatie veshchestva v kapelnoi modeli protoplanetnogo oblaka”, Astr. vest., XXVII:5 (1993), 3–25

[23] E.M. Galimov, A.M. Krivtsov, A.V. Zabrodin, M.S. Legkostupov, T.M. Eneev, Iu.I. Sidorov, “Dinamicheskaia model obrazovfniia sistemy Zemlia-Luna”, Geokhimiia, 2005, no. 11, 1139–1150

[24] E.M. Galimov, “Obrazovanie Zemli i Luny iz obshchego supraplanetnogo gazopylevogo sgushcheniia”, Geokhimiia, 2011, no. 6, 563–580

[25] E.M. Galimov, “Analiz izotopnykh sistem (Hf-W, Rb-Sr, J-Pu-Xe, U-Pb) primenitelno k problemeformirovaniia planet na primere sistemy Zemlia-Luna”, Problemy zarozhdeniia i evoliutsii biosfery, ed. E.M. Galimov, Krasand, M., 2013, 47–59

[26] J.H. Jeans, Astronomy and cosmogony, Cambridge, 1929

[27] Ia.B. Zeldovich, I.D. Novikov, Reliativistskaia astrofizika, Nauka, M., 1967, 654 pp.

[28] E.M. Lifshits, ZHETF, 16 (1946), 587

[29] W.B. Bonnor, Appl. Math., 8 (1967), 263

[30] Dzh. Bond, K. Uotson, Dzh. Uelch, Fizicheskaia teoriia gazovoi dinamiki, Mir, M., 1968, 556 pp.

[31] F.A. Baum, S.A. Kaplan, K.P. Staniukovich, Vvedenie v kosmicheskuiu gazodinamiku, Izdatelstvo fiz.-mat. literatury, M., 1958, 424 pp.

[32] V.G. Gorbatskii, Kosmicheskaia gazodinamika, Nauka, M., 1977, 360 pp.

[33] A.B. Makalkin, V.A. Dorofeeva, “Stroenie protoplanetnogo akkretsionnogo diska vokrug Solntsa na stadii T Teltsa”, Astr. vest. Issledovaniia Solnechnoi sistemy, 29:2 (1995), 99–122

[34] A.B. Makalkin, V.A. Dorofeeva, “Stroenie protoplanetnogo akkretsionnogo diska vokrug Solntsa na stadii T Teltsa”, Astr. vest. Issledovaniia Solnechnoi sistemy, 30:6 (1996), 496–513

[35] G.V. Dolgoleva, M.S. Legkostupov, L.A. Pliner, “Chislennoe modelirovanie gravitatsionnoi neustoichivosti protoplanetnogo diska v odnomernom priblizhenii. Chast I. Odnorodnaia izotropnaia sreda”, Keldysh Institute preprints, 2016, 049, 44 pp.

[36] N.S. Koshliakov, E.B. Gliner, M.M. Smirnov, Uravneniia v chastnykh proizvodnykh matematichkoi fiziki, Vysshaia shkola, M., 1970, 712 pp.

[37] G. Rivs (red.), Proiskhozhdenie Solnechnoi sistemy, Mir, M., 1976, 569 pp.

[38] R. Ebert, Habilitationschrift, Un. f. Frankfurt-am-Main, 1964